All About Reading Homeschool Review: What Worked for Both My Kids
If you’re searching for an honest All About Reading homeschool review, you’re probably trying to figure out whether one reading program can truly work for different learning styles. That was my exact question when we started—and All About Reading is one of the few programs that genuinely worked for both of my kids…even though they had very different learning styles.
They both eventually aged out of the program reading above grade level. After years of using this curriculum, this is my tried-and-true All About Reading homeschool review.
This post contains affiliate links for products I discuss and love. Please see my disclosure policy for more information.
Why This All About Reading Homeschool Review Includes Two Learning Styles
My kids could not be more different when it comes to learning.
-
One needed structure, clear steps, and predictability
-
The other needed flexibility, hands-on elements, and short, focused lessons
What surprised me was that All About Reading met both of them where they were, without me having to constantly modify or reinvent the lessons.
The program is designed to be systematic and thorough, but it doesn’t feel rigid. That balance made a huge difference in our daily homeschool rhythm.
Open-and-Go Was a Game Changer
One of the biggest reasons we stuck with All About Reading long-term was its open-and-go simplicity.
I didn’t need to:
-
Pre-read long teacher manuals
-
Gather extra materials
-
Plan elaborate lesson extensions
I could sit down, open the lesson, and teach—confident that the instruction was solid and sequential. On busy homeschool days (and let’s be honest, most days are busy), that mattered.
Digital Letter Tiles Worked Better for Us
We used the digital letter tiles, and I honestly wouldn’t do it any other way.
While the physical tiles are great, the digital version:
-
Eliminated setup and cleanup
-
Kept lessons moving smoothly
-
Worked well for both visual and hands-on learners
-
Reduced distractions (no dropped tiles, no sorting)
For my kids, the digital tiles felt intuitive and kept the focus on reading rather than managing materials.
Growing Beyond the Program
Both of my kids eventually aged out of All About Reading—not because it failed them, but because it did its job well.
They moved on reading confidently and above grade level, with strong decoding skills and a solid foundation. We didn’t rush through the program, and we didn’t linger unnecessarily either. We followed the pacing that fit each child, and that flexibility was key.
Who I Think All About Reading Is Best For
Based on our experience, I’d especially recommend All About Reading if you:
-
Have kids with different learning styles
-
Want a structured program without it feeling overwhelming
-
Prefer open-and-go lessons
-
Appreciate multi-sensory instruction
-
Want something that grows with your child rather than rushing them
Final Thoughts
There are many good reading programs out there, but All About Reading earned our trust over time. It worked consistently, calmly, and effectively—for both of my kids.
In a homeschool full of trial and error, that kind of reliability is something I truly value.
If you’re considering it and wondering whether it can really work for different learners, my answer—based on lived experience—is yes.
